Disclosure and Abuse in a Primary Care Setting
Childhood maltreatment is a major determinant in physical and mental illnesses, and is associated with increase health risk behaviors. While there are a number of treatment modalities that have been used and shown effective with this population, many of those who have been maltreated do not disclose such abuse and trauma experiences unless they are specifically asked and therefore are not offered these treatment modalities. In fact, the experience of MSAHC providers is that 20-30% of our adolescents questioned have experienced either physical or sexual abuse.
The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) recommends pediatricians and other health care providers serving children to routinely screen for child maltreatment and abuse. This is necessary because many patients, especially adolescents, do not willingly or spontaneously report past or current victimization events. In contrast to medical tests that examine the presence or absence of disease where high specificity and sensitivity is desired for diagnosis, the diagnosis of childhood abuse is usually made after extensive investigation interviews have been conducted by designated law enforcement and child protective service agencies. Thus, screening for child maltreatment represents only the first step in a lengthy process to substantiate and validate the occurrence of abuse. Unfortunately, many clinicians are very reluctant to screen trauma backgrounds in the absence of spontaneous patient disclosure, fearing that such lines of inquiry are invasive, irrelevant, needlessly distressing, or overly complicated. Research suggests that a great majority of patients, regardless of their race, gender, socioeconomic status, age, and education level, would welcome physician screening about assault experiences. Clearly, there is a need to develop, evaluate, and employ reliable screening methodologies to meet the AAP's recommendation for primary care pediatricians to do routine screening of abuse.
The "Disclosure Study" examines the ways in which a psychosocial health history is taken. Patients who consent to participate are randomly assigned to one of four survey methods for eliciting information on abuse:
- Self administered paper and pencil
- Audio Computer Assisted Interview (ACASI)
- Structured clinical interview
- Unstructured clinical history
This work will help pediatricians, adolescent medicine specialists and other providers screen for abuse.
In spring of 2007 we closed the study to recruitment. Six hundred male and female adolescent primary care patients completed the study. Results of the study are forthcoming.
